4 - 1Brendan Hunt, Melissa Villaseñor and Joe Buck Sep. 27, 2023- 4 - 2Kel Mitchell, Kim Fields and Penn Jillette Oct. 04, 2023
- 4 - 3Rashad Jennings, Marcellus Wiley and Jared Allen Oct. 18, 2023
- 4 - 4Gabriel Iglesias, Noah Mills and Danielle Pinnock Oct. 25, 2023
- 4 - 5Natasha Leggero, Roy Wood Jr. and Kyle Brandt Nov. 15, 2023
- 4 - 6Tim Gunn, Debbie Gibson and Luis Guzman Nov. 29, 2023
- 4 - 7Lauren Lapkus, Ego Nwodim and Jeff Ross Dec. 06, 2023
- 4 - 8Lil Rel Howery, Paula Abdul and Matt Rogers Dec. 13, 2023
- 4 - 9Sarah Levy, Christian Siriano and Kristen Ritter May. 06, 2024
- 4 - 10Neil deGrasse Tyson, Robin Thede and Tony Hale May. 13, 2024